Carbon 3D materialized out of nowhere at the TED conference yesterday and introduced a whole new approach to polymer-based 3D printing that might in fact be the leapfrog innovation we’ve all been hoping to see come into existence. The new Continuous Liquid Interface Production technology (CLIP) uses light and oxygen to “continuously grow objects from a pool of resin instead of printing them layer-by-layer.” Because I know that everyone is going to be wondering immediately how much it costs: they didn’t release that information yet.
3 Insanely Cool Things About Carbon 3D’s CLIP Technology:
- Mind Blowing Speed: 25-100 times faster than conventional 3D printing
- Commercial Quality: Produces objects with consistent mechanical properties
- Material Choice: Enables the use of a wide range of polymeric materials
Dr. Joseph DeSimone, CEO and Co-Founder of Carbon3D, said, “Current 3D printing technology has failed to deliver on its promise to revolutionize manufacturing. Our CLIP technology offers the game-changing speed, consistent mechanical properties and choice of materials required for complex commercial quality parts.” Dr. DeSimone is a phenomenal scientist and entrepreneur and the recipient of numerous awards, including the Lemelson-MIT Prize for inventors and the 2009 NIH Director’s Pioneer Award. Dr. DeSimone is also credited with over 100 issued patents and nearly 300 published articles.
A Closer Look At How The CLIP Technology Works:

We know that 3D printing, as it exists today, works by printing or curing one layer at a time. Instead of this layer-by-layer approach, the Carbon 3D printer uses “a tunable photochemical process.” What this means is that, by carefully controlling the interaction of UV light, which creates the photopolymerization, and oxygen, which inhibits the reaction, CLIP continuously grows objects from a pool of resin at speeds 25-100 times faster than traditional 3D printing!
The key component is a special window that is both transparent to light and permeable to oxygen, similar to a contact lens. By balancing the amount of oxygen that comes in and out of the window, CLIP creates a “dead zone” in the resin pool that is only tens of microns thick where it is impossible for photopolymerization to occur. Then a series of “cross-sectional images of a 3D model are played like a movie into the resin pool from underneath” and the physical object just emerges (like the T-1000 from Terminator 2) from just above the dead zone.
What’s truly phenomenal about this approach is that it seems to have created a technique that yields parts with the structural integrity of injection molded parts, at least according to Carbon 3D. The mechanical properties would often vary depending on the direction of the prints layer-by-layer. I haven’t seen it up close, and I’ve reached out to find out more information, but Carl Bass mentioned this at REAL 2015 (without mentioning the company’s name – to my chagrin). If what they say is true, then this is a breakthrough. The new CLIP could solve two of the three big obstacles (speed, price, reliability) to widespread adoption, as it could produce far more consistent, reliable and predictable mechanical properties. It’s smooth on the outside, and totally solid on the inside, which alone is a game-changer.

In near perfect stealth-mode, Carbon3D has raised $41 million in funding since 2013, starting with Sequoia Capital, with Series A financing in 2013, and with Silver Lake Kraftwerk for their series B round.
Jim Goetz, Carbon3D board member and Sequoia partner said, “If 3D printing hopes to break out of the prototyping niche it has been trapped in for decades, we need to find a disruptive technology that attacks the problem from a fresh perspective and addresses 3D printing’s fundamental weaknesses. When we met Joe and saw what his team had invented, it was immediately clear to us that 3D printing would never be the same.”
Some of the key figures behind this major 3D printing breakthrough are: Professor Joseph DeSimone (Chancellor’s Eminent Professor of Chemistry at UNC), Professor Edward Samulski,(Cary C. Boshamer Professor of Chemistry at UNC) and Dr. Alex Ermoshki (CTO and Co-founder).
We’ll keep you posted as the story develops!









While the print does look amazing, what I dont see is what scale the Eiffel Tower was printed. To me it appears that the model is only 2 inches tall. Granted a FFF printer would take almost an hour for the same print. Yet the printer that they are printing with is a small surface. I am concerned why we are not witnessing it on a 150mm build plate. Mind you it is only my perception. While I do look to see more happen on a larger scale, my impression is that to ramp it up it doesnt have the same results. Also how long until the corporation of stratasys steps in and claims patent infringement? That is what happened to the last person whom created a similar design wasnt it?
we don;t care
What is the maximum resolution at the present?
this is still layer by layer
“cross-sectional images…” still means that its catalyzing one layer at a time similarly to dlp projection printing.
What seems novel is its application of controlled oxygen. However, current pdms layers still use a similar a “dead zone” to inhibit the cure of the grown material to the build plate
I agree- the 3D printing industry is really losing goodwill with consumers because of wild and bogus claims like this. This is still layer-by-layer. Even if the layers are so thin that with a microscope you can barely make them out, doesn’t make the process “layerless”!!
Yeah if there is no seam there are no layers. How is this so difficult to understand. Okay let me simplify. If there are layers of space in between the atoms. the object has layers. if the atoms are secure and in order. there are no layers. Understand? A mold has no layers. A cut has no layers. A print has layers. This is not a print, this is generation. this could be considered real time molding.
The process of dlp stereolith still has cross layer polymerization. It depends on depth of cure
Even if it has layers, it still is better then the alrenative
Reminds me of how metal will weld together in space because there is no oxidized layer inhibiting it. I do believe this is a continuous generation of the object becase the object never leaves the pool of material, thus it doesnt introduce contaminants as the model progresses. The traditional 3D printer is alway stacking over exposed layers.
“Typically, oxygen inhibition leads to incomplete cure and surface tackiness when photopolymerization is conducted in air (17, 18). Oxygen can either quench the photoexcited photoinitiator or create peroxides by combining with the free radical from the photocleaved photoinitiator (fig. S1). If these oxygen inhibition pathways can be avoided, efficient initiation and propagation of polymer chains will result. When stereolithography is conducted above an oxygen permeable build window, continuous liquid interface production (CLIP) is enabled by creating an oxygen-containing “dead zone,” a thin uncured liquid layer between the window and the cured part surface. We show that dead zone thicknesses on the order of tens of micrometers are maintained by judicious selection of control parameters (e.g., photon flux and resin optical and curing properties). Simple relationships describe the dead zone thickness and resin curing process, and, in turn, result in a straightforward relationship
between print speed and part resolution. We demonstrate
that CLIP can be applied to a range of part sizes from undercut
micropaddles with stem diameters of 50 μm to complex
handheld objects greater than 25 cm in size.” – Continuous Liquid Interface Production of 3D Objects, Science Magazine
This paper is great, everyone should read this.
No! It is NOT layer by layer as it is like watching live action video. Imagine that the video, live, not with frame rate, just actual transmission of video and the same speed curing of what is projected. seamless, not layered.
Live action video is still defined by a frame rate. Which is a series of single frames per second. Just because the process is continuous (and all together amazing) it still is layer by layer. Otherwise the growing of the part wouldn’t be linear along the z axis. It builds upon the last grown part.
Well no because there are only so many frames you can have before it IS SEAMLESS. Duh.
Let’s be clear. The phenonema which makes video possible is persistance of vision. It is the process where a person’s mind “interpolates” continuous motion through a series of related still images. It is never seamless because as it is now it is described by many still images.
I think this research is awesome. However, what defines CLIP from envisiontec’s ERM? Its not the continuous building. Its the control of oxygen.
Yes, let’s be clear. think more of audio, seamless, it is continuous, not stop and go. Human perception and seamless are not one in the same.
Even slowing and speeding up again does not define a frame rate, nor eliminate the claim of seamless. a ball rolling slowly and accelerating and slowing again IS seamless and a video projection not via captured video, but by projected CGI can, indeed, be seemless.
somehow, this technology uses another method of projecting light in a continuous method other than video?! I think not, therefore we have to assume that normal projection methods apply and are defined by frame rate. Unless of course they invented another method of projection which is altogether more ground breaking than this.
LOL, LIVE video does not use frame rates!unless it is projecting into an older frame rate display, wherein live video, naturally seamless, is converted into frames. but then again, keep on writing about what you know not!
Wow, the ignorance displayed here is astonishing. ALL video is recorded or transmitted in frames, with live video being no exception, just as ALL displays, e.g. Tvs, monitors, projectors, display video in frames. Look at any display on planet earth and it will tell you how many hz it is. Typical hz values for displays are 30, 60, 120 and 240. And for your information, hz=fps (frames per second) that the display is capable of displaying. Now, the frame rate of the source material may or may not match the frame rate capability of the display (hz). I.E. 120fps source material displayed on a 60hz monitor means it will only actually display every other frame of recorded material, or 60fps source on a 120hz monitor means it displays every recorded frame for 2 cycles. Ideally, the source should match the display for the best experience. Once videos start having a high enough frame rate, or fps, it appears seamless to the human eye, which usually starts happening over 20fps for casual viewing and over 60fps if you are really scrutinizing it, but some material benefits from even higher frame rates, such as fast moving action like sports. Most movies are filmed at 24fps, with the Hobbit being the first one recorded at 48fps.
With this printer, suppose it moves about an mm per minute. That means, if they are using a 240hz projector, they are getting 14400 slices, or frames, per mm. This is high enough resolution to appear, and basically be, seamless. This is just like resolution with TVs or monitors, as in they all have pixels. They more pixel density it has, the more seamless it appears, but it doesn’t mean it no longer has pixels.
You really should look things up on google, or at least know what you’re talking about before before posting completely wrong information online, like saying ‘live video does not use framerate’ and talking about ‘older framerate displays’. Even the newest displays use frames or hz. Just higher ones to appear more seamless to the human eye.
YEah, go and argue with the guys building this. I sure that they will be really impressed by you calling their seamless system, not seamless.
BTW, video and this is not the same thing. Video retains frame rate due to the recorded video is captured in frames per second, but it IS just like radio, perfectly possible to have actual real time seamless video, but you keep on knowing all things. It seems to make you happy.
WRONG! Recording and reproducing video and audio work VERY differently, and cannot be compared. And I guarantee you that the people who made this would agree with me and politely explain to you, as if talking to a child, that their claim of seamless means ‘virtually seamless’ as in undetectable to the human eye, in much the same way that an ultra high resolution display will have no discernible pixels (to the human eye), but that doesn’t actually mean it has no pixels. While it is theoretically possible to have seamless video IT HAS NEVER BEEN DONE. Period. These guys are no different.
Praise you!
And yes, video and this ARE the same thing, as the projector is only capable of projecting FRAMES. And it is nothing like radio, as radio is broadcast and reproduced fully in analog form, where this is most certainly NOT.
Unfortunately, very unfortunately, people are being distracted by bias information… yes they came up with a dead zone and that is great, BUT in order to solidify resin at that speed you need a great deal of light, Lumens… and that is the reason why ALL this guys videos only focus on the little tiny resin tank!!!! the only time when you see the whole unit is at the TED talks video and if you pay attention… to the size of the bottom container of the unit you will get what every one is missing… a 35,000 Lumen projector…priced at 130,000 USD!!!! this is not a scam but in a way it is… they have raised 41 million dollars thanks to this charade… they have not informed that you need 35,000 Lumens to print this crappy 51 cm object!!!!
This is not true. I met the students working on a SLA-based project at UNC in a guided tour of a couple of research projects there, a long time ago (last year), and I now realize the project I saw there was CLIP. They printed a replica of the Eiffel tower for each of our 3 tour members in a grand total of ten minutes each, to give us as souvenirs.
They specifically stated that the machine they used cost 10 grand in parts. These were the grad students working on it, not their marketing or PR branch. They were printing in acrylic resin too, so that was cool. Another cool thing they mentioned was that if you want to print small, the time it takes scales weirdly (I don’t know how to explain it) so it is faster to build something bigger like say normal 3d prints and not on the millimeter scale. That was an interesting quirk.
By the way, I realize now this thread is a bit old, so sorry about that.
If you want to get anal retentive about it, every single thing in the universe is “layer by layer” at the atomic level. Nothing is truly “continuous,” if you’re focused on semantics. It is easily understood by the majority of us that by “continuous” they mean “without visible layers” like everything else in the universe.
This is “layerless 3D printing” the same way “4D printing” exists: only in the hype. I expected a layerless printer to use some sort of 5axis 3d toolpathing.
it is layer less dumb dumb
Wow Really Cool 6:35 Min ! That’s Great!
In the video of the Eiffel tower the build speed seems to increase towards the end of the build as the cross section of the tower decreases. If this is a DLP system where the projection covers the entire bed you would expect the time taken to cure a given depth to be independent from the amount of materials that needs curing on each layer, but this doesn’t look like the case – unless the mirror in the schematic is actually there to focus the DLP projection onto a ‘zone’ of the build area (e.g. quadrants). Or there might be some physical mechanism moving the DLP chips under the permeable membrane. However, it works the speed is impressive and would only increase with more DLP chips. $40M of VC money will buy a lot of chips, optics and Z-stages.
I think they mean layerless because it seems to be a continuous flow rather than a process that is split into discreet layer build instructions.
You could argue that layers still exist if the “movie” of images has a frame rate, but I guess what they mean is the the process instructions aren’t broken down layer by layer: You don’t watch a film frame by frame to experience the story.
Anyhow, it looks pretty good!
Agreedo, Martyn!
It would be actually layerless if a ‘frame rate’ did not exist.
a live stream without layers can be replicated by the digital image of an object. Using the mathematical ability of a computer one can get to a point where layers do not actually exist, because any number can really be divided by 2, infinitely. a projection of this type would not have layers any more than dropping something through a particle beam would be destroyed by layers.
Something past through a beam and through time would have a single layer based on the rate in which it is passed through at any given moment. Otherwise light wouldnt travel through space.
Frame rate, by definition, is a stop motion effect. live action, a thing falling has NO frame rate, but our translating it into a recorded video gives a frame rate that SEEMS (only) to be fluid motion. Perhaps if you were to think of an audio format that has no ‘frame rate’ you would understand better.
That would be fine if it were projecting audio but it is not. Its projecting slices in a continuous manner.
Its projecting light at particular instances in a manner that is fluid but still can be defined and finite at any particular moment. It’s built off of the last polymerization in rapid succession but is still layer upon layer. The motion blurs the layers but they are still there and controlled by oxygen.
LOL, did you SEE the picture? do you REALIZE that layers of a regular 3D print have no layers within the layers? think of this as the entire print is one layer. Otherwise you are imposing your ignorance on the FACT that seamless is possible. IF you knew what you were talking about you would realize that it IS possible to show video without frames. 3D design program drawings ARE layerless! ALL that is needed is to project a descending or ascending view, seamlessly and the fluid, continuous motion of the bed upwards give a true seamless print.
You are prejudiced into thinking that it DOES use or MUST use layers, rather than projecting a fluid, seamless image, which is fully possible, instead of it being displayed on your LCD monitor, it is projected to an ultraviolet projector.
NO LAYERS, get over it, it is real it is happening, adjust your paradigm to match reality, because reality is not going to adjust to you!
🙂 funny
“Otherwise light wouldnt travel through space.”
That has got to be the most ignorant thing ever said!
nice
how then would you describe light that doesnt travel but just exists? There is no precident
More idiocy, you pretend that a moment in time, frozen and separated, being TAKEN as a layer, means that Layers are automatically part of nature, and it is sheer idiocy! Just because you can MAKE a layer, does not mean it was always a layer. If it was you would not HAVE to make it, btw, do you even understand the words you write?
Do you understand the REASON for slicer programs?
See, the 3D model HAS NO LAYERS, but must be transformed INTO layers.
Once again, stupidity upon stupidity, and the worst part of it is, you do not even seem capable of understanding the error you are in!
Lol, you do realize that calling other people idiots for not agreeing with your misinformation makes you look like an even bigger idiot than what you are attempting to portray them as?
Yes, a 3D model basically has no layers as it exists inside the computer, but in order to be printed by the projector, which displays images in frames, that 3D model has to be broken down into layers, as stated in the very article above you are misrepresenting:
“Then a series of “cross-sectional images of a 3D model are played like a movie into the resin pool from underneath” and the physical object just emerges (like the T-1000 from Terminator 2) from just above the dead zone.”
FYI, “cross-sectional images of a 3D model” means LAYERS!
THIS PRINTER STILL PRINTS IN LAYERS!!!! It just prints lots of them very quickly, one after another, just like video.
Theoretically, a new technology could be developed which is indeed frameless and truly seamless, using vector projection or something, but this has never been done.
Reread your last sentence there and apply it to yourself.
Smart people understand that saying a position held or a thought proclaimed being idiocy does not equal calling a person, an idiot.and no, if you looked at the picture of the graining that is continuously diagonally vertical, there are no layers. But go on, continue in idiocy.
See, a live video need not have layers, whereas a recorded video is, usually, recorded in frames per second. Each frame would be a layer, but as, again, the picture shows, there are no levels and there is no claim of the printer or program filling in the layers, that is your claim. How is it that you think YOU can make claims for the people producing this when they are saying layerless?
WOW you sure are the arbiter of truth, huh?
Yes, please, look at the grains in the image. THOSE ARE THE LAYERS!!!!!
You again display your lack of understanding of the way video works, and your misconception that ‘live’ video is somehow different from recorded video. It is not. You also claim that recorded video is ‘usually’ recorded in frames per second. This is also wrong. It is ALWAYS recorded in frames per second. 100% of the time. No exceptions.
Just because the layers are very small and difficult or even impossible for the human eye to perceive does not mean they don’t exist.
You think that just because they call it ‘layerless’ means it actually is so? You have never heard of ‘marketing terms’ or ‘hype’? Wow, it must be easy to sell you just about anything.
What a rube!
Now I will just call YOU an idiot. Ever see a cross section of steel, looks a lot like this and no, steel, molten and solidified does not have layers, however it DOES have grain in the crystal lattice.
And, again, Video CAN, indeed be broadcast without frames, it has been done, early on, lol. and, modern ]LDC, LED and Plasma digital screens do have a Hz refresh rate, true, but they do not truly have individual frame flashes like old CRT units. In fact, that is why eye strain is almost gone in modern screens, BECAUSE of the non replacement of individual frames. only the individual pixels change as needed, not the entire picture, unless the entire picture is replaced. And why is that?
It is because the technology follows the development of the past. true frameless video was abandoned due to technological limitations. if someone gets digging and decides to take it up again, we will have true life frameless video, once again. it will be actually like true life.
Praise you
Yes, I have seen steel, and it does NOT look like this. It is grainy in a somewhat similar way, but does not have ANY lines like this does. It has an even, uniform granular structure, with no lines in it at all.
And again, you are an idiot for repeatedly making claims about video being broadcast without frames. IT HAS NEVER BEEN DONE. I challenge you to search google for the answer. Post a link supporting your claim. You can not, since it doesn’t exist. Early on, video was recorded on film, frame by frame, and displayed frame by frame.
And once again you display a patent misunderstanding of display technology by claiming “]LDC, LED and Plasma digital screens do have a Hz refresh rate, true, but they do not truly have individual frame flashes like old CRT units” Yes, they truly do have individual frame flashes like CRT monitors. The difference is that CRTs displayed their frames interpolated, which means that first they would display the odd numbered lines of the frame, then the even lines, so there were 2 flashes per frame. Modern displays are progressive, which means they display the entire frame, all lines, at once. The pixels don’t shut off between frames like old CRTs did, but it is still displaying its content frame by frame.
And no, pixels don’t simply change as needed, the screen redraws itself entirely according to its HZ. Just because a pixel stays the same color through multiple frames, doesn’t mean it is not being redrawn, and only “changing as needed.” This is why there is a new technology called g-sync and freesync for video games, since video games are rendered at varying frame rates, which don’t always match up with the monitors fixed refresh rate, causing mismatched lines. The technology allows for the monitor to adjust its frame rate to match the frame rate being output by the graphic card on the fly. This problem of mismatched lines would not happen if the pixels simply “changed as needed.” You really don’t understand how modern displays work. Google it.
And also no, frameless video was never abandoned because it never existed, in any form. You are just making things up. It is in fact being pursued, and has for a long time, and would be the holy grail of video. No one would have ever pursued any other tech if frameless ever existed. They didn’t have the holy grail and throw it away to pursue an inferior tech. They never had it. And it is tremendously difficult to implement. It will be quite a while before we have frameless recording and display.
Please, please search google and actually learn some information about what you are talking about before making ridiculous and false claims from your imagination.
“FYI, “cross-sectional images of a 3D model” means LAYERS!”
no it does not, unless you are now the arbiter of language, as well. A cross section is a cut away or a view of a side or other predetermined type.
LOL, you don’t need to be the arbiter of language in order to understand it, as you apparently do not. Yes, a “cross sectional image of a 3D model” is, in fact, the very definition of a LAYER!
Sorry, pointing out your idiocy is not = to my having stated that static light exists, without traveling. you can make up anything you wish, but assigning your idiocies to me is a bit above your pay grade!
Yes, if frame rate did not exist, it would be layerless. But frame rate DOES exist, and currently can NOT be gotten around. Therefore, this is NOT layerless.
“CLIP proceeds via projecting a continuous sequence of UV images (generated by a digital light-processing imaging unit) through an oxygen-permeable, UV-transparent window below a liquid resin
bath. The dead zone created above the window maintains a liquid interface below the advancing part. Above the dead zone, the curing part is continuously drawn out of the resin bath, thereby creating suction forces that constantly renew reactive liquid resin. This nonstop process is fundamentally
different from traditional bottom-up stereolithography printers, where UV exposure, resin renewal, and part movement must be conducted in separate and discrete steps.” – Continuous Liquid Interface Production of 3D Objects, Science Magazine.
I’m excited to see whether they can deliver on what they promise! I still have some open questions: Won’t these “self-curing” resins be toxic/hard to handle?
What is the border between dead zone and regular resin? Why doesn’t the dead zone expand upwards?
Don’t they have to make sure that this border is planar so that they cure according to the model? How woudl they do that.
I have no idea, but the fluid is UV light cured, so even if the fluid is safe, UV is still harmful.
This technique already has existed for several years.
Formlab Form 1 kickstarter was completed in 2012:
https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/formlabs/form-1-an-affordable-professional-3d-printer/
And here is a video of 3DL Print using the technology in as early as 2011: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iCCFGI0KhfQ
In the video one can see that the light source is on for ~3s (for curing) and off for ~6s (for recoating). The innovation is that CLIP allows you to contiously leave the lightsource because the part is continously recoated.
Not quite. The light source is NOT continuously on. Each layer still has to be intermittently exposed to the section image for a fixed time interval. The “continuous” aspect of CLIP comes from the fact that there is no “peel” step interrupting each layer exposure. This peel and reset has been a staple in SLA for a while and is one of the major failure points, and the biggest time consumer, for any SLA print – the Carbon3D eliminates this step. That’s the innovation to the SLA process.
SLA has been around since the 80s. I can remember being a teenager and watching a documentary about a man who had his skull and part of his face reconstructed using a SLA print after a horrific motorcycle accident. DLP is a fairly new addition to SLA, replacing lasers, and the contactless (no peel) printing technique that the Carbon3D is using is very new to the process.
It is not a new technology, – just has some improvements. I think they want to gain glory and patents.
Honestly, how many years will this be even remotely affordable.
Does anyone know if the material cost is higher than standard models currently in use?
I’m sold on the print quality, but the real question is the price. Are we going to see the usual mega gouging that 3DSystems and the rest have been doing for 30 years?
Unfortunately, very unfortunately, people are being distracted by bias information… yes they came up with a dead zone and that is great, BUT in order to solidify resin at that speed you need a great deal of light, Lumens… and that is the reason why ALL this guys videos only focus on the little tiny resin tank!!!! the only time when you see the whole unit is at the TED talks video and if you pay attention… to the size of the bottom container of the unit you will get what every one is missing… a 35,000 Lumen projector…priced at 130,000 USD!!!! this is not a scam but in a way it is… they have raised 41 million dollars thanks to this charade… they have not informed that you need 35,000 Lumens to print this crappy 51 cm object!!!!
You don’t need to spend $130,000 to produce 35,000 lumen. A 150w bulb can produce 2,600 lumen. So you would only need 14 bulbs or equivalent. Priced at about a few $$ a bulb.. its cheap. You might need a more focused beam, but in all fairness I’m not sure where you are getting $130,000 from.
Yes you do need to spend that money, because that is the price of a 35,000 Lumen projector and that is what this guys are using… saying you will used 14 light bulbs makes no sense… are you aware of how a 3d printer works? if so please let us know…
how can you use 14 light bulbs…
I didn’t say you could work this 3D printer with 14 light bulbs, don’t be sardonic. I am saying that 35,000 lumens is not an expensive amount of light to produce. Now the projector you allude to in your comment.. do you know the exact model they are using or have you just googled what an equivalent would cost? You say this is a “charade” strong words, so I’m certain you can back this claim up!? Please elaborate..
In the meantime I would add that prototypes will always be more expensive and as they don’t have a sellable model to evaluate, it seems premature to shoot down this very clever technology based on your observation.
Well, I assume you just googled how many light bulbs you need to make 35,000 Lumens and just posted that comment… you could be a less bit naive. You did say, indirectly, that you could print with light bulbs… are you aware or not how a 3D printer works?
If you do understand how they work and the relationship between the amount of light and the photo initiator in the resin you could understand that your light bulb comment is completely our of place and superficial.
Presenting a unit that is not saleable and taking 41 million dollars in research just for that “clever” technology… is not really clever technology; is clever people who know how to raise capital…. it seems premature to you, because you need to research a bit more how photoactive resins work.
In regards of the price of a projector…that, you can look up as well… here is a clue… you need to be able to do a bit of reverse engineering, which would include, dimensions on a object!!! and use that information together with the required electrons per second on photo active initiators (Zigma for example) and then cross that information with available projector in the market… with a little effort you will understand…
Is a commercial unit required to evaluate a technology?
Are you aware that oxygen facilitates resin solidification contrary to what they say?
Have you read there patent?
The unit works and it is real, but they will not be able to sell it, simply because they require a huge amount of Lumens and that is expensive, plus the oxygen permeable glass that also has a value per square inch that makes it unpractical… don’t be lazy now… do some research before you make your light bulb comments…
Here is my thinking, maybe we can find some common ground..
No I didn’t google how many light bulbs it can take to make 35k lumens, I just did some simple arithmetic, as 35k lumens of light can be produced in many ways, I wanted to get a straight forward gauge for the simplest way to achieve this amount, I’m not suggesting and never did, that you would use this technique, but you must admit there is huge differential between simple production of this amount of light and a projected version that requires more manipulation of the beam (even possibly colours, as all projectors can do). So I wanted to gauge how (in simplest terms) you can produce this amount of light. It might be that the projector that they require doesn’t need to be as sophisticated as high powered commercial projector which produces 4k images, but mere has the horsepower of a lot of light. Also in future production, prices of components could be a lot cheaper if they are:
a) produced in-house,
b) sourced on a large scale
c) purchased through wholesale channels
d) purchased cheaper from a competitor, maybe even overseas, China etc.
e) requisitioned especially from a capable producer for a cheaper price
All these angles could largely affect the price. It is also the case that when the technology matures, they find a way to produce the print with less light.
You are right however that I haven’t done any research, and frankly I don’t need to, to make an observation. I can see the machine works and the precedent of previous examples of new tech show that the cost of producing “one” is never the same as when mass production starts to take over and competition is rife. New tech always costs a lot more, until production (and demand) begin to make the necessary economies of scale.
Also I don’t have a problem with your comment as such, you are entitled to your opinion, but I would add, you do try to smash them over the head with your opinion. Have you lost some of your own money with them (this $41m is some of it yours?). You seem pretty angry and calling it all a charade, well that that does seem premature, because any new technology that is such a game changer is going to require some pretty big hurdles.
So tell me Diego, do you know how many electrons per second on photo active initiators this machine requires? You seem to have a lot of information on the machine, please share some of the specs..
I do know that placing a projector like the one they use is in a way deceiving… because they are so expensive that it simply impossible to get something out to the market… if you buy Form1 resin and provide the resin with more then 350,000 LUX it takes hundreds of a second to solidify… if you add more Lux to it, it gets faster… I do know how much electrons you require… I do have enough information… if I give a number to you would that prove anything to you? you just wish to argue for the sake or arguing… I have seen it work, it is awesome… the problem as I see it is that it will never hit the market… to expensive… my initial comment is focused on the fact, that they come out with a technology that cant be used, they raise capital and then what?…. if you wish to learn on how photo active resin works I have already provided you were you should start your own research… I just find it lazy to keep asking and not doing a couple of clicks and a few minutes to reading… I am sure by your comments you have no clue of how this printers works… and you got upset when realizing your comment on the light bulbs was superficial… so now you call me angry… you don’t provide much valuable information that one can use… patents are free public documents …go read it and learn… again don’t be so lazy… 🙂
Ok so lets say my comment on the light bulbs is irrelevant to the discussion. What you are saying essentially is that these guys are stealing peoples money? Is that what you mean by charade? That they are taking $41m for a tech that will never see the market!?
(and I don’t have time to research though I would like to, thats not laziness, simply that I have many other things in my life that I cannot drop to look up patents, manufacturing techniques of 3d printing tech. etc)
Ok, so I’ve just read their patent.
The only mention of a projector is a DLP Lightcrafter Dev Kit which costs about £420.
Perhaps you could tell us exactly where you are getting your information from?
Here is the patent:
http://www.google.com/patents/US20150097315?cl=en
so silly, people arguing layers or no layers, like people saying an Apple computer is the same as an HP cause they both are made of plastic and metal…does this new method make a better part faster? if yes then accept it, quit looking for some stupid reason its not exactly layer-less!
Okay, so why doesn’t the dead zone expand upwards?